MSP vs. In-House IT: The Real Cost Comparison
What does it actually cost to hire IT staff vs. pay a managed service provider? The numbers are rarely what they appear to be.
The true cost of in-house IT
Most businesses see the salary line. They miss everything else.
Direct costs
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics May 2023 Occupational Employment data, the median annual wage for a Network and Computer Systems Administrator is $90,520, and for a Computer Support Specialist it's $59,660. An IT generalist at a small business falls somewhere in between — budget $65,000–$85,000 for base salary alone in most markets, higher in metro areas.
Employers pay an additional 25–35% on top of that for benefits, payroll taxes, and mandatory employer contributions. On an $75,000 salary, that adds $18,750–$26,250 — bringing total annual compensation to $93,750–$101,250 for one person.
Hidden costs most businesses forget
- Recruiting: SHRM estimates average cost-to-hire is $4,700; IT roles average $8,000–$15,000 with recruiter fees
- Onboarding time: 2–3 months before productivity reaches full speed
- Certifications & training: $2,000–$5,000/year to keep skills current
- Security tools: EDR, RMM, backup software, SIEM — $3,000–$8,000/year
- Coverage gaps: One person works ~2,000 hours/year — no nights, weekends, or vacation coverage
- Turnover: Average IT employee tenure is 2–3 years; each departure restarts the $8,000–$15,000 hiring cycle
A single mid-level IT hire at $75,000 base salary costs approximately $95,000–$110,000 all-in annually — before tools, training, or recruiting. For a 10-person business, that's $9,500–$11,000 per employee per year for IT coverage that still doesn't include nights or weekends.
What managed IT actually costs
MSP pricing is per-user and all-inclusive — tools, monitoring, helpdesk, and security bundled together.
Industry-standard MSP pricing
Comprehensive managed IT services in the U.S. typically run $100–$175 per user per month for a full-service bundle that includes endpoint management, patching, helpdesk, Microsoft 365 administration, and security monitoring. This is the pricing range cited by CompTIA channel research and confirmed by industry benchmarking from Datto and Kaseya.
A 10-person company on a mid-range plan at $135/user/month pays $16,200/year — compared to $95,000+ for a single in-house hire who can't cover after-hours or provide specialized security expertise.
What's included in MSP pricing
- 24/7 monitoring and alert response
- Helpdesk support during business hours (and after-hours for critical issues)
- Patch and update management across all devices
- Security tools: EDR, email filtering, backup software — included, not extra
- Multiple engineers with different specializations (not limited to one person's knowledge)
- No turnover risk — your coverage doesn't disappear when someone quits
Side-by-side: 10-person business, one year
aspect Managed Service Provider
- 10 users × $135/user/month: $16,200/year
- Security tools: included
- Training & certifications: on the MSP, not you
- Recruiting: not your problem
- Turnover risk: none
- Total: ~$16,200/year
- Coverage: 24/7 monitoring, team of engineers, documented SLAs, no gaps
In-house IT hire
- Base salary: $75,000
- Benefits & payroll taxes: $22,500
- Security tools (EDR, backup, RMM): $6,000
- Training & certifications: $3,000
- Recruiting (amortized over 2-year tenure): $6,000
- Total: ~$112,500/year
- Coverage: business hours only, one person's expertise, no after-hours response without additional pay
For most businesses under 50 employees, a managed service provider costs 60–80% less than a comparable in-house hire — and delivers broader expertise, around-the-clock monitoring, and no coverage gaps. The cost crossover point (where in-house becomes economical) is typically around 75–100 users with complex, specialized IT requirements.
When in-house IT makes sense
Better fit for aspect Managed IT
- Under 75 employees — MSP almost always more cost-effective
- Businesses that need security expertise, not just helpdesk support
- Seasonal businesses that can't justify a full-time hire year-round
- Growing businesses that need scalable support without hiring friction
- Businesses with compliance requirements (HIPAA, GLBA, PCI DSS) that need documented, auditable controls
Good fit for in-house IT
- 100+ employees with high daily IT support volume
- On-site hardware requirements that need immediate physical access
- Highly regulated environments requiring embedded IT knowledge (large healthcare systems, financial institutions)
- Internal software development with security requirements baked in
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2023
- SHRM, "The Real Costs of Recruitment," 2022
- ITIC (Information Technology Intelligence Consulting), 2023 Hourly Cost of Downtime Survey
- CompTIA, "MSP Pricing and Profitability Research," 2022–2023
- Datto/Kaseya, Global State of the MSP Report, 2023
Find out what the right level of IT support costs for your business.
Book a free assessment — we'll look at your environment and give you a straight answer on what you actually need.